| BCFL |
West All Stars |
BCFL | East All Star | ||||
| 2015 | Offense | 2015 | Offense | ||||
| OC | |||||||
| 1st Team | Tyler | Gardner | Broncos | OC | |||
| 2nd Team | Ron | Newman | Cincy Bulldogs | 1st Team | Jonathon | Gauze | Warriors |
| 3rd Team | Cliff | Hoenie | Dukes | 2nd Team | Nathan | Newton | Spartans |
| HM | Cliff | Metzger | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | Jason | Blake | WV Lightning |
| OG | HM | Joeseph | James | WV Storm | |||
| 1st Team | Fred | Whittle | Queen City Hitmen | OG | |||
| Justin | Ruterford | Comets | 1st Team | Juice | Duncan | WV Lightning | |
| 2nd Team | Donald | Smith | Cincy Bulldogs | Dan | Haney | Spartans | |
| Jacob | Ware | Broncos | 2nd Team | Zack | Phillips | WV Bulldogs | |
| 3rd Team | Chris | Barkau | Cincy Bulldogs | Robby | Logan | Warriors | |
| Lavar | Marshall | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | Eddie | Dixon | WV Storm | |
| HM | Austin | Rutledge | Broncos | Matt | Owens | Spartans | |
| HM | Ashley | McNeely | WV Storm | ||||
| OT | Chad | Bennett | Warriors | ||||
| 1st Team | Jake | Nicols | Broncos | OT | |||
| Michael | Dace | Dukes | 1st Team | CJ | Huffman | WV Lightning | |
| 2nd Team | Cody | Bray | Cincy Bulldogs | Steven | McNair | WV Storm | |
| Pat | Hudson | Queen City Hitmen | 2nd Team | Billy | Cole | WV Storm | |
| 3rd Team | Chis | Reynolds | Queen City Hitmen | Brian | Spradlin | Wildcats | |
| Jacob | Milner | Broncos | 3rd Team | Ralph | Mosley | Warriors | |
| HM | Eric | Little | Dukes | Jack | Brewer | WV Lightning | |
| HM | Mark | Owens | Spartans | ||||
| QB | Brandon | Scott | Spartans | ||||
| 1st Team | Josh | Finch | Broncos | QB | |||
| 2nd Team | Austin | Howell | G-Men | 1st Team | Chuckie | Erby | WV Lightning |
| 3rd Team | Ryan | Erkins | Queen City Hitmen | 2nd Team | John | Sweickart | Spartans |
| HM | Nick | Hayes | Dukes | 3rd Team | Justin | Lunsford | Warriors |
| TE | HM | Chris | Holt | WV Storm | |||
| 1st Team | Corey | France | Broncos | TE | |||
| 2nd Team | Eniss | Williams | Queen City Hitmen | 1st Team | Mich | Fewell | WV Lightning |
| 3rd Team | Greg | Presley | Dukes | 2nd Team | Anthony | Williams | Spartans |
| FB | FB | ||||||
| 1st Team | V.J. | Anderson | Broncos | 1st Team | Dalton | Stamm | Spartans |
| 2nd Team | Jermaine | Cardwell | Queen City Hitmen | 2nd Team | Luke | Brown | Warriors |
| 3rd Team | Nick | Metzger | Cincy Bulldogs | 3rd Team | Aaron | Slusher | WV Lightning |
| HM | Marcus | Sewell | Dukes | TB | |||
| TB | 1st Team | Jerome | Smith | WV Lightning | |||
| 1st Team | Robert | Givens | Broncos | 2nd Team | Demetri | Gray | WV Storm |
| 2nd Team | Jimmy Dan | Conners | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | Jontez | Jones | Warriors |
| 3rd Team | Robert | Bouldin | Dukes | HM | Duke | Edward | Spartans |
| HM | D.J | Alexander | Comets | WR | |||
| WR | 1st Team | Tyler | Adkins | WV Storm | |||
| 1st Team | Paul | Jones | Boncos | John | Prittecht | Rivermonsters | |
| Tae | White | G-Men | 2nd Team | Jermaine | Payton | Warriors | |
| 2nd Team | Tristan | Saunders | Queen City Hitmen | LJ | Adams | Spartans | |
| Devin | Kendrick | Cincy Bulldogs | 3rd Team | Andrew | Nelon | Wildcats | |
| 3rd Team | Antuian | Brown | Queen City Hitmen | Chris | Maxwell | WV Lightning | |
| Adrian | Solomon | Broncos | HM | Deyartus | Dudley | WV Lightning | |
| HM | Eric | Claxton | Dukes | Andre | Canada | Warriors | |
| Ronold | Jackson | Comets | AP | ||||
| AP | 1st Team | Santonio | Smith | Warriors | |||
| 1st Team | Jordan | Albright | Broncos | 2nd Team | Lj | Adams | Spartans |
| 2nd Team | David | Hampton | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | PJ | Jones | WV Lightning |
| 3rd Team | Rodney | Stone | Cincy Bulldogs | HM | Purcell | Lash | WV Storm |
| HM | Tim | O'Brien | Comets | RS | |||
| RS | 1st Team | LJ | Adams | WV Storm | |||
| 1st Team | Clay | Ballenger | Queen City Hitmen | 2nd Team | Deyatrus | Dudley | WV Lightning |
| 2nd Team | Angelio | Proffit | Comets | 3rd Team | Sean | Bunting | WV Storm |
| 3rd Team | Tony | Briges | G-Men | HM | Santonio | Wilson | Warriors |
| HM | Eric | Colven | Dukes | P | |||
| P | 1st Team | Josh | Parsons | Spartans | |||
| 1st Team | Tim | O'Brien | Comets | 2nd Team | Mike | Dawkins | Warriors |
| 2nd Team | Michael | Sechrist | Dukes | 3rd Team | Glen | Logan | WV Storm |
| 3rd Team | Luis | Sanchez | Queen City Hitmen | HM | Mich | Fewell | WV Lightning |
| HM | Ryan | Roberts | Cincy Bulldogs | K | |||
| K | 1st Team | Josh | Parsons | Spartans | |||
| 1st Team | Luis | Sanchez | Queen City Hitmen | 2nd Team | Mark | Daheel | Warriors |
| 2nd Team | Nicko | Recul | Cincy Bulldogs | 3rd Team | Glen | Logan | WV Storm |
| 3rd Team | Paul | Jones | Broncos |
| BCFL | West All Star | BCFL | East All Stars | ||||
| 2015 | Defense | 2015 | Defense | ||||
| CB | CB | ||||||
| 1st Team | Chris | Bryant | Broncos | 1st Team | Jeremy | Hall | WV Lightening |
| Paris | Holland | G-Men | Daitone | Robinson | Spartans | ||
| 2nd Team | Dominick | Galbraith | Broncos | 2nd Team | Adam | Lowe | WV Storm |
| June | Frazier | Cincy Bulldogs | Tre | Murrell | WV Lightening | ||
| 3rd Team | Demario | Pleasant | Comets | 3rd Team | Ty | Reves | WV Storm |
| Taylor | Lucket | Cincy Bulldogs | Mason | Jordan | Warriors | ||
| HM | Brandon | Wheeler | Queen City Hitmen | HM | Chance | Freeman | Warriors |
| Brad | Davis | Queen City Hitmen | Delo | Mire | Rivermonsters | ||
| FS | FS | ||||||
| 1st Team | Jordan | Albright | Broncos | 1st Team | Jay | Harris | WV Lightening |
| 2nd Team | Derrick | Sims | Dukes | 2nd Team | Corey | Goodman | WV Storm |
| 3rd Team | Quentin | Gayden | G-Men | 3rd Team | Snook | Martin | Warriors |
| HM | Tyler | Cosby | Queen City Hitmen | HM | Jack | White | Spartans |
| SS | SS | ||||||
| 1st Team | Josh | Thorpe | Cincy Bulldogs | 1st Team | Andrew | Nelson | Wildcates |
| 2nd Team | Kyle | Sacks | G-Men | 2nd Team | Chris | Robinson | WV Lightening |
| 3rd Team | Jalen | Mathis | Broncos | 3rd Team | David | Poff | WV Storm |
| HM | Kenneth | Hamner | Dukes | HM | Christian | Ellis | Spartans |
| OLB | MLB | ||||||
| 1st Team | Abe | Smith | Comets | 1st Team | Thomas | Abernathy | WV Lightening |
| Gannon | Mathis | Broncos | 2nd Team | Ben | Danahue | Warriors | |
| 2nd Team | Rodney | Goins | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | Rhamel | Hatcher | Spartans |
| Justin | Blunk | G-Men | HM | Demetr | Gray | WV Storm | |
| 3rd Team | Kyle | Hogan | Queen City Hitmen | OLB | |||
| Jesse | Bruce | Broncos | 1st Team | Shay | Netter | Warriors | |
| HM | Jake | Davis | Comets | Bo | Bailey | WV Storm | |
| Mitchell | Hamilton | G-Men | 2nd Team | Tyler | Ellis | Rivermonsters | |
| MLB | Mike | Dickerson | WV Lightening | ||||
| 1st Team | Noah | Bailey | Broncos | 3rd Team | Dion | Dean | WV Lightening |
| 2nd Team | James | Jackson | Cincy Bulldogs | Jeff | James | WV Storm | |
| 3rd Team | Dalton | Craig | Dukes | HM | Brandon | Slusher | Spartans |
| HM | Rocky | Johnson | G-Men | Charles | Johnson | Warriors | |
| DE | DE | ||||||
| 1st Team | Aaron | Harris | Broncos | 1st Team | Jason | Haynes | WV Lightening |
| Justin | Young | Cincy Bulldogs | Larry | Love | WV Lightening | ||
| 2nd Team | Wyatt | Wagner | Broncos | 2nd Team | Deontae | Baker | WV Storm |
| Curtis | Marshall | Queen City Hitmen | Steven | Lee | Warriors | ||
| 3rd Team | Matt | Bailey | Dukes | 3rd Team | Alec | Meeker | Spartans |
| Justice | Lewis | Cincy Bulldogs | Mike | Cottigham | WV Bulldogs | ||
| HM | Tavon | Hamilton | Queen City Hitmen | HM | Michael | McFarland | WV Storm |
| Christian | Laferty | G-Men | Chris | Maddox | Spartans | ||
| DT | DT | ||||||
| 1st Team | Brandon | Mitchell | Broncos | 1st Team | Charlest | Cyrus | WV Lightening |
| Robert | Dyess Jr. | G-Men | Jason | Williams | WV Storm | ||
| 2nd Team | James | Meyers | Dukes | 2nd Team | Demarius | Williams | WV Lightening |
| Donald | Gaskins | G-Men | Dominique | Johnson | Warriors | ||
| 3rd Team | Fred | Whittle | Queen City Hitmen | 3rd Team | Mike | Stage | Rivermonsters |
| Ray | Fredrick | Broncos | Chris | Echols | WV Bulldogs | ||
| HM | Jarrell | McCloud | Cincy Bulldogs | HM | Thad | Mack | WV Storm |
| Jowon | Briggs | Queen City Hitmen | Justin | Ohm | Spartans |